Marine Parents Logo Marine Parents a Place to Connect and Share®
  HOME   |   ONLINE STORE   |   SITE MAP    
About Us   |   Support Our Troops   |   What's New   |   A Place to Connect and Share®   |   Meet Our Marines   |   Outreach, Inc. is an IRS-approved 501(c)(3) public charity.
        Marine Parents for families of Marines and Recruits to Connect and Share

Slideshow image

Since your web browser does not support JavaScript, here is a non-JavaScript version of the image slideshow:

Marine Parents a Place to Connect and Share

Marine Parents EGA Shop

Marine Parents Gold Star Family Support

Marine Parents Gold Star Luminary Initiative

Marine Family Network

Marine Parents is an Official Licensee of the United States Marine Corps

Marine Parents Operation Prayers and Letters

Marine Parents and Recruit Parents

Team Marine Parents

Marine Parents is a USMC Charity Partner

Marine Parents Whats After Boot

Marine Parents Warrior Support Team

Marine Corps Marathon and Charity Partner

Marine Corps Marathon and Charity Partner

Warrior Support Team Join Their Fight

Marine Parents on Amazon Smil

Marine Parents Celebrates the Marine Corps Birthday

Marine Parents and CFC 57100

Marine Parents Commandants Reading List

Marine Parents Care Packaget Project

Marine Parents Gold Star Family Support

Marine Parents Operation Prayers and Letters

Team Marine Parents

Marine Parents Online Retail Store

Marine Parents EGA Shop Online Store

Marine Parents Gift Certificates

Marine Parents Gols Star Luminary Initiative

Marine Parents Marine Corps Marathon Bibs

Marine Parents Meet Us at the Marine Marathon

Marine Parents Recruit Poolee Kits

Marine Parents Send  Us Your Photos

Marine Parents Support Our Troops

Marine Parents Care Package Project

Marine Parents Purplhe Heart Hero Support

Marine Parents Operation PAL

Marine Parents Team Marine Parents Thank Our Corporate Sponsors!   |   Advertise With Us!

News & Announcements

Monthly Columns & Special Features

Past Newsletters

2015 Newsletters
2014 Newsletters
2013 Newsletters
2012 Newsletters
2011 Newsletters
2010 Newsletters
2009 Newsletters
2008 Newsletters
2007 Newsletters
2006 Newsletters

Past Announcements

Receive our Newsletter! Enter email:
  • cfcx200
  • CRL2x200
  • EGA-shopx200
  • poolee-kitsx200
Gitmo Detainee Trial Draws to a Close: Fair, Balanced & Transparent Procedures
From Our Columnist, Kyndra Miller Rotunda*

Kyndra Rotunda
Archive Columns

Today, August 4, 2008, JAG lawyers face off in Guantanamo Bay to deliver closing arguments in the Hamdan case. Hamdan is the alleged bodyguard and driver for Osama bin Laden. According to prosecutors, he was part of bin Laden's inner circle; swore allegiance to bin Laden; attended al Qaeda training camps; transported weapons for bin Laden; and helped bin Laden evade capture by U.S. Special Forces in Afghanistan at a most crucial time -- in the weeks after September 11th, when U.S. forces were hot on his heels. Hamdan was bin Laden's bodyguard and get away driver. Because of co-conspirators, like Hamdan, Osama bin Laden has gotten away with murder.

Prosecutors in Guantanamo Bay presented mountains of evidence, lasting nearly two weeks, to six jurors who will decide whether Hamdan is guilty. If the jury finds Hamdan guilty, he could spend the rest of his life in prison.

The Case Against Hamdan
The U.S. has been criticized for unfair trials that supposedly give prosecutors an edge. But, the facts don't support that charge. What was revealed over the last few weeks is that the military commissions being held in Gitmo are fair, balanced, and afford detainees fundamental due process.

Many of the early criticisms were like the boy who called wolf. Hamdan wasn't excluded from his trial (like defense counsel said he would be); he had an opportunity to present evidence and cross examine witnesses against him; he had the right to remain silent; he can only be found guilty if the prosecution proves its case "beyond a reasonable doubt;" and Hamdan had access to thousands of documents and boxes of evidence against him. The Government went to great lengths to de-classify evidence for trial. It wasn't a rigged trial conducted in the shadows, like defense counsel said it would be. At times the Judge decided issues in favor of Hamdan; and at other times he decided issues in favor of the Government. It was open, fair and transparent.

Hamdan's Lackluster Defense
Defense Counsel steered far away from the facts and presented less than two days worth of evidence. It relied on a statement from alleged 9-11 Mastermind Khalid Sheikh Muhammad, who said (in writing, because he refused to testify on Hamdan's behalf), that Hamdan was only a low-level participant in the 9-11 conspiracy. In KSM's view, Hamdan was not fit to be a terrorist, but only fit to drive them around from place to place. But even if we believe KSM (who was not subject to cross examination), under the crime of conspiracy, low level participants are also culpable. It doesn't matter that the get-away driver didn't rob the bank. He is just as culpable as the bank robber, because he made it possible in the same way that Hamdan made 9-11 possible.

What Happens Next?
Beginning today, prosecutors and defense counsel will present their closing arguments. The prosecutor has the burden of proof, so it will get the last word. Then, the case will go the jury who will decide whether to convict Hamdan. It will also decide the appropriate sentence if he is convicted. Prosecutors have requested life in prison, but the jury could find Hamdan guilty and impose a lesser punishment. The jury will deliberate until they reach a decision, which could range from a few hours to several days. They could feasibly reach a decision by the end of this week.

What happens to Hamdan if the jury finds him guilty?
Hamdan will be imprisoned by the U.S. military and will probably remain in Guantanamo Bay. He will likely be held away from other prisoners, who have not been tried and convicted of war crimes. He will be held in prison-like conditions.

What happens to Hamdan if the jury finds Him not guilty?
Ordinarily, a defendant is free to leave when a jury returns a not-guilty verdict. But, Hamdan's case is different because it occurs during a time of war and the U.S. was already holding Hamdan as soldier for the other side. Under the laws of war, each side is permitted to hold soldiers from the opposing side until the war is over. Holding prisoners is not a form of punishment; it is detention in order to bring the war to a quicker end by preventing soldiers from returning to the battlefield. That is why laws of war (including the Geneva Convention), specify that prisoners will be held until the end of hostility.

If the jury finds Hamdan not guilty, he will return to his cell in Guantanamo Bay where he will stay until U.S. troops come home from the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq. But, he will enjoy greater freedoms than if he is convicted. Most detainees who are not facing trial in Gitmo for war crimes (and presumably those found not-gulity of war crimes), enjoy significant freedom of movement. They live in open bays with 10 to a bay and receive up to 12 hours of recreation times each day. During that time they can play any number of sports including ping-pong, soccer or basketball. They can check out books from the library, watch movies on video, garden, visit the exercise facility, take classes in English, or their native language, play board games, or just mingle and chat together in common areas.

In fact, if Hamdan is like other detainees he might not want to leave Gitmo! When the Government offered release to one detainee, he asked to stay. Others were released to Albania and said they preferred "captivity" in Guantanamo Bay over freedom in Albania.

Whether the jury decides to acquit or convict Hamdan, the U.S. should be proud of the way this historic trial was conducted in Gitmo, with fair, balanced, and open procedures. When procedures are fair, we can expect some acquittals and some convictions. The scales of justice tip both ways.

*Kyndra Rotunda is a law professor at Chapman School of Law, a Major (JAG Officer) in the Army Reserves, former Gitmo Prosecutor and author of Honor Bound: Inside the Guantanamo Trials (Carolina Academic Press, June 2008), available at


Marine Family Network™®
Recruit Parents™
What's After Boot™

  • Recruit Parents
  • Team Marine Parents
  • Care Package Project
  • Operation Prayers and Letters
  • Purple Heart Hearo Support
  • Caregivers Support Group
  • Gold Star Family Support
  • Luminary Initiative
  • 11 Years of Service
Our Programs

  • egashop-slide-C-1227
  • egashop-slide-CS-4815
  • egashop-slide-Q1017-BT
  • egashop-slide-AOY-1034
  • egashop-slide-AOA-1479
  • egashop-slide-AOH-0839
  • egashop-slide-AOH-5074
  • egashop-slide-CY-5079
  • egashop-slide-C-4028
  • egashop-slide-CP-0112
  • egashop-slide-CS-1274
  • egashop-slide-CY-1831
  • egashop-slide-HSW-4896
  • egashop-slide-DWM-3873
  • egashop-slide-GND-5014
  • egashop-slide-GNG-0901
  • egashop-slide-GNT-3993
  • egashop-slide-HSP-2600
  • egashop-slide-JE-3689
  • egashop-slide-JEF-5063
  • egashop-slide-JER-1423
  • egashop-slide-JES-0393
  • egashop-slide-JEW-1211
  • egashop-slide-LP-0327
  • egashop-slide-ME-2511
  • egashop-slide-Q1005-SW
  • egashop-slide-Q1034-2529
  • egashop-slide-Q1060-SL
  • egashop-slide-Q1084-0622
  • egashop-slide-Q3232-SU
  • egashop-slide-Q4000-4052
  • egashop-slide-Q4007-SL
  • egashop-slide-SBK-3818
EGA Shop
Team Marine Parents
Team Marine Parents™
The Care Package Project
Care Package Project™
Wounded, Ill, and Injured Warrior Support Team
Warrior Support Team™
Operation PAL
Operation PAL ™
After the Corps
After the Corps ™
Gold Star Family Support
Gold Star Family Support™
Gold Star Luminary
Luminary Initiative
Receive our Newsletter! Enter email:
How can we help you?

Marine Parents Combined Federal Campaign #57100 Show Me Heroes Hiring Veterans in Missouri is a Marine Corps Charity Partner Eleven Years of Service to Marines and their Families Shop for Marine Corps items at the EGA Shop IBM and Marine Parents Partnership in Charity AmazonSmile and Marine Parents Charity MarineParents is a Guidestar Exchange Gold Participant, Inc.
PO Box 1115
Columbia, MO 65205
Phone (573) 449-2003
Copyright © 2003-15, Inc. ~ All Rights Reserved Worldwide is an IRS-approved 501(c)(3) public charity,
a Marine Corps Charity Partner, and Official Marine Corps Trademark Licensee.
Site Map   |   Statements of Use   |   Outreach Programs   |   Join Team Marine Parents
Neither the United States Marine Corps
nor any other component of the
Department of Defense has approved,
endorsed, or authorized this service.